Show News

Practical growth and hiring lessons from Theo Paphitis 

A more honest look at growing a recruitment agency 

If you run a recruitment agency, you’ll know that growth rarely feels straightforward. 

On paper, it can look simple enough - win more clients, hire more consultants, fill more roles. In reality, it’s much less predictable. Performance varies across teams, hires don’t always work out, and what worked six months ago suddenly stops delivering the same results. 

That’s why hearing from someone like Theo Paphitis at Recruitment Agency Expo 2026 is so useful. His experience spans decades of building and turning around businesses, and while his world isn’t recruitment-specific, many of the challenges he spoke about are exactly the same ones agency owners face every day. 

What stood out most was how grounded his advice was. There was no complicated framework or over-engineered strategy — just a clear focus on people, ownership, and staying close to what’s really happening inside the business. 

Why mindset plays a bigger role than strategy 

Theo spoke openly about leaving school at 16 and navigating undiagnosed dyslexia. It would have been easy to see that as a disadvantage, but instead it shaped how he approached business. 

As he put it: 

“I’ve never been afraid of problems - I’ve always seen them as something to solve.” 

That perspective is particularly relevant in recruitment, where challenges are constant rather than occasional. Deals fall through, candidates change their minds, and clients shift priorities at short notice. There’s no version of running an agency where those things don’t happen. 

What tends to separate growing agencies from those that plateau is not whether problems occur, but how they’re handled. Leaders who stay calm, focus on solutions, and keep momentum tend to build businesses that can absorb setbacks without losing direction. 

Improving performance starts inside your agency 

One of the strongest themes in Theo’s talk was ownership. When something isn’t working, it’s easy to look outward - at the market, competition, or economic conditions. 

But more often than not, the issue sits much closer to home. 

“Most businesses already have the answers - they just haven’t asked the right people yet.” 

For recruitment agency owners, this is worth paying attention to. Performance issues are often visible day-to-day but not always addressed directly. 

That might include: 

• Consultants who are busy but not billing  

• Processes that slow down placements  

• Inconsistent follow-up with candidates or clients  

• Gaps between top and bottom performers  

Rather than immediately looking for new tools or new hires, it’s often more effective to understand what your best people are doing well and where others are struggling. 

Those conversations tend to surface practical improvements that can be implemented quickly - and often have a bigger impact than introducing something entirely new. 

Hiring will always involve risk - even when you get it “right” 

Hiring is one of the most important and most difficult parts of growing a recruitment agency. It’s also one of the areas where even experienced leaders get it wrong from time to time. 

Theo was very open about this: 

“You can meet someone who says all the right things - but until they’re in the business, you don’t really know.” 

That uncertainty is something recruitment agency owners understand better than most. Strong interviews, good references, and previous billing history don’t always translate into performance in a new environment. 

Over time, what becomes more important is how quickly you recognise when something isn’t working and how you respond. Holding on too long to the wrong hire can have a wider impact on team morale and performance, while acting decisively allows the business to move forward. 

Equally, each hire - whether successful or not - adds to your understanding of what works for your business specifically, not just in general. 

What actually makes a strong recruitment consultant 

It’s easy to assume that success in recruitment comes down to experience or sector knowledge. While those things matter, they’re rarely the deciding factor. 

Theo’s view cuts through that assumption: 

“I back people, not just ideas. Because without the right person, even the best idea goes nowhere.” 

In recruitment, the same applies. A strong desk, a good market, or a well-known brand can only take someone so far. What tends to drive consistent performance is how individuals approach their work over time. 

The consultants who build sustainable success are usually those who: 

• Take ownership of their desk rather than waiting for direction  

• Maintain consistent activity levels, even when results dip  

• Stay resilient through the inevitable ups and downs  

• Build relationships rather than relying on quick wins  

These qualities aren’t always obvious at the hiring stage, but they become very clear once someone is in the role. 

Why growth strategies fail without the right people 

As agencies look to scale, there’s often a focus on expansion - new markets, new sectors, or new service lines. 

While these can be effective growth strategies, they depend heavily on who is leading them. 

One of the recurring lessons from Theo’s experience, particularly through Dragons’ Den, is that ideas alone are rarely enough. Execution is what determines success, and execution always comes back to people. 

For recruitment agency owners, this is particularly relevant when: 

• Launching a new division  

• Expanding into a different geography  

• Building out a leadership team  

Without someone who genuinely owns that area and is accountable for its performance, even strong opportunities can struggle to gain traction. 

Building a business that grows over time 

Another of the interesting reflections from Theo’s talk was around Small Business Sunday (#SBS). It wasn’t created as a large-scale business strategy, but it grew into a widely recognised network through consistency and engagement. 

There’s a useful parallel here for recruitment agencies. 

Growth doesn’t always come from a single major decision. More often, it’s built through: 

• Consistent delivery to clients  

• Ongoing engagement with candidates  

• Building a reputation within a specific niche  

• Incremental improvements in performance  

These are not always the most visible activities, but they are often the ones that create long-term stability and growth. 

Bringing it back to recruitment agency growth 

There’s a tendency in recruitment, as in many industries, to look for new strategies, new tools, or new approaches when growth slows. 

What Theo’s talk reinforced is that many of the answers are already within the business. 

Clear thinking, strong people, and a willingness to address issues directly tend to have more impact than constantly introducing new layers of complexity. 

For recruitment agency owners, that often means focusing on: 

• Improving consultant performance before scaling headcount  

• Hiring for ownership and consistency, not just experience  

• Staying close to what’s happening day-to-day  

• Building processes that support, rather than hinder, delivery  

These are not new ideas, but they are often the ones that make the biggest difference when applied consistently. 

Continue the conversation at Recruitment Agency Expo 

If you’re looking to take a step back from the day-to-day and think more strategically about how your agency grows, events like Recruitment Agency Expo provide that opportunity. 

The event brings together recruitment agency owners, leaders, and suppliers to share practical insights on: 

• How to scale a recruitment agency  

• Improving consultant performance and billing  

• Hiring and retaining high-performing recruiters  

• Using technology effectively within recruitment  

It’s less about theory and more about conversations and ideas that can be taken back into your business and applied in a meaningful way. 

👉 Register your interest now for next year’s event and start planning ahead